The release of “Me Before You” has been met with a firestorm
of criticism from the disabilities community. Based on on the bestselling novel
by Jojo Moyes, the film tells the story of Will Traynor, a wealthy, handsome businessman
paralyzed after a motorbike accident and Louisa Clark, a pretty yet provincial
young woman, hired as his caregiver. Will, played by Sam Clafin of “The Hunger
Games” fame and Louisa, played by Emilia Clarke of “Game of Thrones,” eventually
fall in love. Unfortunately, that’s not where the story ends.
Why are people with disabilities and their allies up in arms?
There are several reasons:
1. The role of Will
Traynor is played by an actor without a physical disability
Given the paucity of roles for actors with disabilities,
many in the disabilities community are incensed by the fact that someone with
quadriplegia was not cast in the high profile role.
“The casting of non-disabled actors in disabled roles is
pervasive across the industry, despite the fact that there are numerous
talented disabled actors languishing without work,” writes S.E. Smith for Care2. “Seeing
non-disabled people represent the disability experience is offensive,
especially when the experience being depicted is itself so offensive.”
2. The film’s depiction of life
with disability is extremely negative
Since so
few films and television programs have characters with disabilities, viewers
who don’t have disabilities or who don’t know people with disabilities only
learn about their experiences from examples in films such as “Me Before You.”
The result? People view the lives of people with disabilities as being tragic,
miserable and pitiful.
“Me
Before You” capitalizes on existing widely held negative ideas about disability
and exploits them as fodder for entertainment,” writes Emily Ladau, in a piece
for Salon. “Prior to becoming disabled, Will was successful and
happy, but Moyes implies that anything good in life will come to an end when
disability becomes a reality.”
3. The film feels
emotionally manipulative
Some disabilities advocates have pointed out that the film
is “calculated
to play upon the emotions of the viewer by evoking disability.” And it seems to
work.
“It's
become almost a running joke that if you want to win an Oscar, play a disabled
character,” writes Kathleen Hawkins of the BBC. Think: Daniel Day Lewis for his performance in “My Left Foot,”
Dustin Hoffman in “Rain Man,” and Eddie Redmayne for “The Theory of
Everything.”
4. (Spoiler
Alert) The film’s ending implies that having a disability is a fate worse than
death.
In the end, despite
his love for Louisa and everything else he has to live for, Will Traynor chooses
to end his life. His reasons? He doesn’t want to live if he can’t do the things
he did before his accident, he doesn’t want to be a burden to Louisa and his
family and he doesn’t want her to end up resenting or pitying him in the
future.
Members of Not
Dead Yet UK, a group that’s
part of
a global alliance of people with disabilities who oppose euthanasia
and assisted suicide picketed
the film’s premiere and posted this statement on its website: “ Not Dead Yet UK
is deeply concerned to
see yet another film which casts non-disabled people as disabled people and
shows the lives of disabled people as not worth living.”
Have you seen or read “Me Before You?” We’d love to hear what
you think. Talk to us here or on Facebook or Twitter.
No comments:
Post a Comment